Distance:
Audio:
Steadiness:
Heads:
Focus/Light:
Balc. L50°
Avg.Rating:
| DVDylan ID: | D1139 |
| Recording type: | Audience |
| City/Venue: | New York City, NY, USA/Madison Square Garden Arena |
| Date: | Monday, 19th November 2001 |
Never-Ending Tour Concert #1379
Special thanks for the video to THE UNIDENTIFIED TAPERS, TOM P. & RAYGUN.
Additional thanks for the audio to THE UNIDENTIFIED TAPER, RF & BUGS.
Edited, sound upgraded & authored by YASSOU.
- Disc 1 (1:20:20:17) (Songs 1-12) (Tracks 1-14]
-Opening Titles [fade in to titles; extracted 13:10 audio from video soundtrack to fill cut upgrade source then used AS-1 until its song due to cut in AS 2 during intro]
-Introduction
-Wait For The Light To Shine
-It Ain't Me, Babe
-A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall [added 3-frame still before song for a/v sync]
-Searching For A Soldier's Grave
-Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum
-Just Like A Woman
-Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues [2-frame still added before song for a/v sync]
-Lonesome Day Blues [2-frame still added before song for a/v sync]
-High Water (For Charley Patton) [trans. to next song cut 54:16 on VS 1/used VS 2 to fill]
-Don't Think Twice, It's All Right [3-frame cut/glitch @59:19:19/1 still + 7 frames for a/v sync]
-Tangled Up In Blue [cut/glitch 15:24 @1:08:48:10/used VS 2 to fill cut and 7:28 more of verse; tape splits before next song/extracted 7:24 audio from video soundtrack to fill gap]
-John Brown [fade to end Disc 1 message over 5:18 black still]- Disc 2 (1:10:58:28) (Songs 13-22) (Tracks 15-26)
-Opening Titles [titles over 20:04 still]
-Summer Days
-Sugar Baby
-Drifter's Escape
-Rainy Day Women #12 & 35
-Band Introductions & Speech [during "Rainy Day Women #12 & 35" with Bob talking about writing and recording songs in New York City; AS 2 audio and VS 1 video cut 1:58:26/used VS 1, AS 1 and extracted audio from video soundtrack to fill]
-Things Have Changed [VS 1 clipped 9:20/used VS 2; trans. to next song cut 16:24/used VS 2]
-Like A Rolling Stone
-Forever Young
-Honest With Me [clipped 3:05:23/used VS 2]
-Blowin' In The Wind [39:03 audio cut before last song/extracted audio from video soundtrack to fill]
-All Along The Watchtower
-End Thanks & Credits [AS 1 & 2 audio cut/extracted audio from video soundtrack to fill end applause; thanks/credits/salute/fadeout]
| Number of discs: | 2 |
| Running time: | 02:32 |
| Video standard: | NTSC |
| Authoring: | DVDs with menu and chapters are circulating |
Disc editor's rating:
5-point rating: 3/5-/5/5/4+
15-point rating: 8/13/14/14/12 (avg. 13.25 A-)
VIDEO SOURCES & LINEAGE:
VS 1: 2 mini-dv tapes (previously uncirculated)
3/3/5/5/4+
Left balcony 50˙
Taper: unidentified Shared by Tom P. & raygun
unknown camera > mini-dv tapes > CANON ZR700 NTSC Camcorder > iMovie 6.03
VS 2: 2 Hi8 tapes (source for D190/D190.su)
3+/3/4/5/4
Right balcony 40˙
Taper: unidentified
Shared by Tom P. & raygun
Hi8 tape > Sony Digital Video Camera Recorder (DCR-TRV480) > iMovie 6.0.3.
AUDIO SOURCES & LINEAGE:
AS 1: LB-11312
LB rating: A
Taper: Unidentified
Shared by RF via trade
Editor cut applause between songs thus creating an a/v sync issue. flac > DropBox > Toast Titanium 11.0.4 > Sd2f disk images > iMovie 6.0.3
AS 2: LB-1265 xref-00704 (same source as LB-1257)
LB rating: A
Taper: Unidentified
Shared by Bugs via ElectricLadyland upload
flac > ElectricLadyland > Toast Titanium 11.0.4 > Sd2f disk images > iMovie 6.0.3
DVD PRODUCTION PROCESS:
Produced by yassou on a MacBook Pro running Lion 10.7.5 and Apple software.
Audio and video assets edited in iMovie 6.0.3; authored, multiplexed and burned to VIDEO_TS folder in iDVD 7.1.2 (Professional Quality 2-pass variable bit rate encoding)
NOTE: The editor used the new-to-circulation left balcony source video except in cases where there were cuts, in which case the previously-circulated (but lower generation) right balcony source was used. A subsequent item will reverse the priority.
3/5-/5/5/4+
8/13/14/14/12 (avg. 13.25 A-)
Left balcony 50˙/Right balcony 40˙
2:31:29:15
PERFORMANCE/HIGHLIGHTS/SPECIAL MOMENTS:
-Dylan's comments about NYC in the band intros
-Dylan's two jokes about Kemper in the band intros
-overall great performance and setlist (see reviews at boblinks)
DISTANCE/POSITION: 8 (camera mostly frames four players, zooms to two players occasionally; shot from left balcony)
AUDIO: 13 (excellent sound albeit a bit on the harsh side; the editor chose to use the harsher source because the other source cut applause between songs which would have necessitated cuts in the video)
STEADINESS: 14 (mostly steady/goes off-target occasionally)
HEADS/OBSTRUCTIONS: 14 (mostly unobstructed)
FOCUS: 12 (excellent color and resolution except on zoom; distance may have limited camera's capability)
EDITING: Probably due to the length of the concert, the source video and audio editors cut applause, even between songs on one audio source; this necessitated video and audio fills as detailed in the set last details; since there were two video sources, one from the left balcony and one from the right balcony, the editor was able to use video clips rather than stills to fill missing/obstructed parts; occasional a/v sync problems were fixed by adding brief stills before some songs.
VIDEO SOURCES & LINEAGE:
VS 1: 2 mini-dv tapes (previously uncirculated)
3/3/5/5/4+
Left balcony 50˙
Taper: unidentified
Shared by Tom P. & raygun
unknown camera > mini-dv tapes > CANON ZR700 NTSC Camcorder > iMovie 6.03
VS 2: 2 Hi8 tapes (source for D190/D190.su)
3+/3/4/5/4
Right balcony 40˙
Taper: unidentified
Shared by Tom P. & raygun
Hi8 tape > Sony Digital Video Camera Recorder (DCR-TRV480) > iMovie 6.0.3.
AUDIO SOURCES & LINEAGE:
AS 1: LB-11312
LB rating: A
Taper: Unidentified
Shared by RF via trade
Editor cut applause between songs thus creating an a/v sync issue.
flac > DropBox > Toast Titanium 11.0.4 > Sd2f disk images > iMovie 6.0.3
AS 2: LB-1265 xref-00704 (same source as LB-1257)
LB rating: A
Taper: Unidentified
Shared by Bugs via ElectricLadyland upload
flac > ElectricLadyland > Toast Titanium 11.0.4 > Sd2f disk images > iMovie 6.0.3
DVD PRODUCTION PROCESS:
Produced by yassou on a MacBook Pro running Lion 10.7.5 and Apple software.
Audio and video assets edited in iMovie 6.0.3; authored, multiplexed and burned to VIDEO_TS folder in iDVD 7.1.2 (Professional Quality 2-pass variable bit rate encoding)
LB notes for LB-LB-11312
LB-rating: A
Taper not identified
(73min+72min), version "d"; mis-described with info ffrom LB-1257
bittorrent download 02/14; different recording than LB-1257 based on
different crowd at end of d1t9; in comparison this has a fuller warmer
sound; (did not listen to all of this)
drop/cut between cdrs. d2t9 1:23. discontinuity pop d2t11 1:03, 2:00, 3:00,
4:08, d2t5 2:54, 3:13 plus some more
LB notes for LB-1265 xref-00704
LB rating: A
Taper not identified
BOOTLEG
3 CDs (74min+74min+79min) (CD 3 is filler)
excellent sound (A); same recording as LB-0542 based on same clapping wavs at end of d1t1; in comparison this has had levels raised with compression and made harsher and narrower
(a bittorrent from 02/11 is a close eac match on d1t1 with fewer digital flaws; described as "JTT, February 2011" with filenames like "Disc 1Bob Dylan - In The Garden 2001_Disc 01Track 01.flac"; xref-00704); drop d3t4 6:27; drop/cut between cdrs; multiple digi-pops starting d3t5 through d3t14
Reviewed by yassou on 02nd February 2014