DVDylan ID: D2009.msu
Recording type: Audience
City/Venue: New York, NY, USA/Madison Square Garden
Date: Sunday, 1st November 1998


3-5/5/5-/5-/4+
8-13/14/13/13/12 (avg. 13.00 A-)
Right balcony 10˙
1:23:57:05
PAL

DIFFERENCES/IMPROVEMENTS OVER FROM MS-190/D2009:
-sound upgraded
-cuts filled with stills and movie clips
-different title and track menus

PERFORMANCE/HIGHLIGHTS/SPECIAL MOMENTS:
-dynamic, NYC-centric, performance
-highly enthusiastic and hip crowd
-Dylan quite talkative, introducing songs, name checking artists, expressing his love
for NYC
-crowd goes wild at “going back to New York City” line of “Just Like Tom Thumb's
Blues”
-fine acoustic set
-Dylan blows great harp on”Don't Think Twice, It's All Right” turning to face the
crowd in the balcony behind the stage
-Baxter’s note-worthy pedal steel, especially on “One Too Many Mornings”
-tremendous take on “Joey”
-a delicate “The Times We’ve Known” with a shout out to Charles Aznavour
-as great a performance of “Blowin’ In The Wind” that you’re likely to hear, with
chilling harmonies by Baxter and Campbell and great tremolo mandolin by Baxter

DISTANCE/POSITION: 8-13 (filmer has a good vantage point; focuses on Dylan, mostly knees up; right panning limited, so Garnier and Baxter get short shrift)

AUDIO: 15 (excellent LB-1468)

STEADINESS: 13 (quite steady once songs get started, even during raucous “Rainy Day Women #12 & 35”)

HEADS/OBSTRUCTIONS: 13 (mostly unobstructed once songs get started)

FOCUS: 12 (fair color and adequate light with soft focus

EDITING: cut and obstructed parts filled with stills and movie clips

Concert # 1042 of The Never-Ending Tour:
Bob Dylan (vocals, electric & acoustic guitar, harp)
Bucky Baxter (pedal steel guitar, mandolin & electric slide guitar, backup harmony)
Larry Campbell (electric & acoustic guitar, backup harmony)
Tony Garnier (electric & standup bass)
David Kemper (drums & percussion)

Filmed by “THE TWO DAVES”
Transferred & disseminated by COOPS2009
Audio recorded by AN UNIDENTIFIED TAPER
Audio shared by TBUICK6 & OUTSIDETLAW
Edited, sound upgraded & authored by YASSOU

VIDEO SOURCE & LINEAGE:
MS-190
Filmed by “The Two Daves”
Transferred & disseminated by Coops2009
D6 A7 S7 H7 F8 BR5 86 mins
VIDEO : Mpeg-2, 720 x 576. 25 fps, pic ratio 4.3. PAL
AUDIO : AC3 Dolby Digital, 48000 Hz, stereo 38.4 kb/s
EC30 tapes transferred to PC via a Panasonic NV-W1 Professional triple standard vhs machine.
Files authored to DVD with Tempgenc DVD Works Author 4
vob files > hd > MPEG Streamclip 1.9.2 > dv > iMovie 6.0.3

COOPS2009 NOTES FOR MS-190:
Now this is more like it, steady generally clear and very sharp, as
well as a very nice show. Certainly one not to miss.

Remember even if you have some of the Daves films already that at best your copies will be 2 generations poorer than anything in the Masters series, so get em all.
These will be with original sound though many will feature as sound upgrades eventually with my two mates Yassou and Madhasse helping out.

AUDIO SOURCE & LINEAGE:
LB-1468
LB-rating: A
Taper unidentified
Conversion: CDR>EAC(secure)>MKW Audio Compression Tool>shn
Conversion by: tbuick6
Shared by OutsideTLaw via trade
no info on equipment or post processing
CDs > hd > Toast Titanium 11.0.4 > SD II disk images > iMovie 6.0.3

LB NOTES FOR LB-1468:
I just received an upgrade of this excellent '98 show. Features the only performance of "The Times We Have Known"; excellent sound

RELATED NOTE FOR LB-4230:
different recording than LB-0000 1468 based on different crowd at end of d1t2; in comparison that one has more bass and fuller sound and makes this one sound light but this has more pleasant vocals; excellent sound [A]; d1t9 has about 30 seconds of silence at end.

NOTES FROM OLAF’S FILES:
BobTalk
...I usually only play these songs when I'm all by myself, but I feel like I'm all by myself now. (before The Times We’ve Known).

Official release
[“The Times We’ve Known”] available on bobdylan.com December 1998.

DVD PRODUCTION PROCESS: Audio and video assets edited in iMovie 6.0.3; authored, multiplexed and burned to VIDEO_TS folder in iDVD 7.1.2 (Professional Quality 2-pass variable bit rate encoding)

Reviewed by yassou on 24th June 2016